The University of Tampa athletic department has a rich history of student-athletes who have earned the highest honor in their respective sports, being named All-American. A total of 651 Spartans have been honored as All-Americans. Tampa All-Americans come from a total of 18 sports. UT's first All-American came in 1951.
This list does not include honorable mention All-Americans.
| Name | Sport | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Mike Adams | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2013-1st |
| Edward Agnew | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2000 |
| Santiago Aguilera | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Shannon Aitken | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2006-2nd, 2007-1st |
| Khalid Aldaboos | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2014, 2015, 2016 |
| Giovanny Alfonzo | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2015-3rd |
| Ernie Alonso | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1986-1st, 1987-3rd |
| Kiersten Anderson | Sport: Beach Volleyball | Years: 2022 |
| Holland Aplin | Sport: Football | Years: 1951 |
| Jordan Augier | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2014, 2015, 2016 |
| Julia Augustsson | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Luanne Baldwin | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1991-2nd |
| Jessie Bardin | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010 |
| Madysen Barnes | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Marisa Barton | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2015, 2016 |
| Steve Bautista | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1996 |
| Brittany Bayes | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2015 |
| Katie Bayes | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2018 |
| Elizaveta Bazarova | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2019, 2020, 2022 |
| Eric Beattie | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2003-1st |
| Bob Beckmann | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1981-3rd |
| Matt Beddow | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2021-3rd, 2022-1st, 2023-1st |
| Joanne Bellard | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1995, 1997 |
| Les Bernys | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003 |
| Lisa Bero | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2012 |
| Sean Bierman | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2012-3rd |
| Madison Birch | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2022-2nd |
| Jeremy Black | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 2008-1st |
| Tiffany Boatwright | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2001-1st |
| Preston Bokos | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1997, 1998, 2000 |
| Anne Bolger | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1993-2nd |
| Runar Borgen | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2014, 2015, 2016 |
| Justin Boza | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2004-3rd, 2005-3rd |
| Caleb Brandon | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Stephanie Branham | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2009, 2010 |
| Jan Brokmar | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1983 |
| Kristjan Brooks | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1995-2nd |
| Jon Brown | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 2001-2nd |
| Ron Brown | Sport: Football | Years: 1968 |
| Madison Brunick | Sport: Beach Volleyball | Years: 2022 |
| Payton Brunick | Sport: Beach Volleyball | Years: 2023 |
| Karl Burdis | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2013, 2014 |
| Meagan Burke | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2012-3rd, 2014-3rd, 2014-1st |
| Ricky Burton | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1996-1st |
| Adrian Bush | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1991-1st |
| Hugo Bustamante | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Jess Butler | Sport: Women's Track | Years: 2010 |
| Lindsay Calimer | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2011 |
| Alex Canney | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2023-3rd |
| Trejan Cannon | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2023-3rd |
| Mike Carlson | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1982 |
| Fletcher Carr | Sport: Wrestling | Years: 1972-75 |
| Tom Carrow | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2001-1st |
| Claude Caruso | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1977-2nd |
| Fred Cason | Sport: Football | Years: 1958 |
| Jenna Cavanaugh | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1990 |
| Michael Chase | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2000, 2001, 2002 |
| Emma Chestang | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2022, 2023 |
| Brian Claar | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1980-3rd, 1981-3rd |
| Erin Clark | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2007-1st |
| Shane Cohen | Sport: Men's Track | Years: 2021, 2022 |
| Alexandra Colley | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2007 |
| Cece Colombo | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2021-3rd, 2022-2nd |
| Fred Cornell | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1990-3rd |
| Jenny Cornwell | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1990 |
| Craig Corrado | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2007-1st |
| Santiago Corredor | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Kalli Cors | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2023-1st |
| Kayla Cox | Sport: Softball | Years: 2012-1st, 2013-1st, 2014-2nd |
| Lee Cruz | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2006-1st |
| Daniel Cucchi | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2005, 2006 |
| EJ Cumbo | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2023-1st |
| Kaleigh Cunningham | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2009-2nd |
| Hayden Curley | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Michael Danner | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2013-3rd, 2014-3rd |
| Jasmine DeGross | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2003, 2004, 2005 |
| Jim DelGaizo | Sport: Football | Years: 1969 |
| Wayne Denswil | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2015, 2016 |
| Felipe DeSousa | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2017-3rd |
| DeCarlo Deveuax | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 1993-2nd, 1994-1st |
| Stephen Dezzi | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2014-2nd, 2015-3rd |
| Angel Diaz | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1998-1st |
| Ralph Diaz | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1981, 1982 |
| Ross Dickerson | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2018-2nd, 2019-2nd, 2020-1st, 2021-3rd |
| Mike Didriksson | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1996 |
| Tyler Ding | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2014-3rd |
| David Dion | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1993-1st, 1994-2nd |
| Kim Dix | Sport: Women's Basketball | Years: 1991-1st (AWSF), 1992-1st (AWSF) |
| Kim Dix | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1990-2nd, 1991-1st |
| Katelen Dixon | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2006-1st, 2007-1st |
| Bo Donaldson | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1996-3rd |
| Makaleigh Dooley | Sport: Softball | Years: 2018-2nd, 2019-1st |
| Missy Dora | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1990 |
| Keith Duncan | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1990 |
| Rodney Ehrhard | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1986-1st |
| Hilary Epling | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1997-2nd, 1998-2nd |
| Haden Erbe | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2022-1st |
| Ellie Eshlemann | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2010, 2011 |
| Courtney Evans | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2007-2nd, 2008-3rd |
| Danielle Faggion | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1996-2nd, 1997-2nd, 1998-1st, 1999-1st |
| Maureen Fahey | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1986, 1987, 1988, 1989 |
| Michael Fall | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1982-2nd |
| Brian Fekete | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2010-2nd, 2012-1st |
| Mary Beth Feldman | Sport: Softball | Years: 2022-3rd |
| Kevin Ferguson | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2007-2nd |
| Amanda Fernandez | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2015 |
| Juancho Fernandez | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2021-1st |
| Melissa Fielder | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2001, 2003 |
| Roy Fink | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2000-2nd, 2001-1st |
| Jeff Finster | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1988-2nd |
| Jeff Fiore | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2009, 2010, 2012 |
| Jared Fitzgerald | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Daniel Fitzpatrick | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2023-1st |
| Madison Flake | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2007, 2008, 2009 |
| Ashley Flateland | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2007-1st |
| Barnabas Fluck | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Jessica Forrester | Sport: Women's Cross Country | Years: 2008 |
| Steve Foster | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1998, 2000, 2001, 2002 |
| Sophia Frece | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Niklas Fredriksson | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1990-2nd |
| Lowell Freeman | Sport: Football | Years: 1959 |
| Ben French | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2021-2nd |
| Bill Frye | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1998 |
| Caroline Frykgard | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2015-3rd |
| Tyler Furrer | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010 |
| Mariah Galhouse | Sport: Softball | Years: 2023-3rd |
| Jim Galmin | Sport: Football | Years: 1964 |
| Amber Galvan | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2001 |
| Megan Garland | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2009 |
| Gabbie Gaunt | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2018 |
| Sammy Gellerstedt | Sport: Football | Years: 1970, 1971 |
| Sierra Gillan | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2022 |
| Kam Gillespie | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2000-2nd |
| Jeff Gilreath | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2004 |
| Heather Glenday | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 |
| Adrian Goas | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2002-1st |
| Megan Goldthorpe | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2020, 2022 |
| Cici Gonzalez | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2014-1st, 2015-3rd |
| Elias Gonzalez | Sport: Men's Cross Country | Years: 2003 |
| Matt Goodwin | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2002, 2003, 2004 |
| Gary Graham | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1991-2nd |
| Lindsey Grater | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Alisha Green | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2007-3rd |
| Alexandria Greenhill | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2012, 2013 |
| Mikael Grennas | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1992-1st |
| Ekaterina Grib | Sport: Tennis | Years: 2020 |
| Shanna Halsell | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2003, 2004, 2005 |
| Martin Hammer | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017 |
| Dick Harte | Sport: Football | Years: 1956 |
| Chelsea Hastings | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2005, 2006 |
| Mikael Haugen | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Luke Hene | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Katy Hennig | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2001 |
| Pia Henrikkson | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1981, 1982, 1983 |
| Deanna Henriott | Sport: Softball | Years: 2011-2nd, 2012-2nd |
| Kevin Hensley | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2005 |
| Don Herndon | Sport: Football | Years: 1957 |
| Alex Hetland | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2009 |
| Marty Heyn | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2017-3rd |
| Sarah Hinkle | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2023-1st |
| Alex Hipolito | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2012, 2013, 2014 |
| Jonathan Holt | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2007-2nd |
| Sorrel Houghton | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2018-1st |
| Donna Howe | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1981, 1982, 1983 |
| Julie Howlett | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2011-3rd |
| Hannah Hudson | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2008, 2009, 2010 |
| Matt Hudson | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1992-1st |
| David Humphrey | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2012 |
| Dan Ingvarsson | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2008-2nd, 2009-1st |
| Ryan Irvine | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2000 |
| Aaron James | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2019, 2020 |
| Tom Janton | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1982, 1983 |
| Sergio Jaramillo | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1995-2nd |
| Zoe Jarvis | Sport: Women's Cross Country | Years: 2019 |
| Zoe Jarvis | Sport: Women's Track | Years: 2021 |
| Jose Jimenez | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2006-3rd |
| Ana Maria Jimenez Rios | Sport: Women's Golf | Years: 2023-2nd |
| Peter Johansson | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1982-1st, 1981-2nd |
| Scott Johnson | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1986-3rd, 1988-3rd |
| Nate Johnston | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 1988-2nd |
| Cindy Jones | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1987 |
| Valerie Jones | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1994-2nd |
| Per-Ake Jonsson | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1984-1st |
| Kristine Kassl | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2010, 2012, 2013 |
| Jim Kavourious | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2000-1st |
| Jesse Kaye | Sport: Football | Years: 1966 |
| Dean Kelley | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1987-3rd |
| Rodd Kelley | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1993-1st |
| Andrew Kew | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2017-1st, 2018-2nd, 2019-1st |
| Bill Key | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1983 |
| Sydney Kin | Sport: Women's Basketball | Years: 2023-1st |
| Jimi Kiner | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001 |
| Daniel Klee | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2004, 2005, 2006 |
| Parker Knollman | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Norbert Kovacs | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2012, 2013 |
| Matt Kramer | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2009 |
| Derek Krell | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2012, 2015 |
| Frank Kuchta | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2008, 2010 |
| Shelby Kuni | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2006-1st, 2007-1st |
| Dan Laidlaw | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2005 |
| Jordan Lala | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2023-3rd |
| Kari Lawrence | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2001 |
| Jordan Leasure | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2021 |
| David Lebron | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2017-1st, 2018-1st |
| Joe Lee | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1979 |
| Jeff Leonard | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1986-3rd, 1987-1st, 1988-1st |
| Mike Lewis | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2008 |
| Ulf Lilius | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1992-2nd, 1994-1st |
| Todd Linder | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 1985-1st, 1986-1st, 1987-1st |
| Hunter Lineback | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2009 |
| Marissa Lisenbee | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2013-3rd, 2014-1st, 2015-2nd |
| John Loddigs | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1990 |
| Sophie Long | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2015, 2018 |
| Bob Lovely | Sport: Football | Years: 1955 |
| Forrest Lundy | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2019 |
| GInger Lynn | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2001-3rd |
| Allison Macsas | Sport: Women's Cross Country | Years: 2003, 2004 |
| Allison Macsas | Sport: Women's Track | Years: 2004 |
| Jackie Majer | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2003,2004 |
| Charlie Manning | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2001-2nd |
| Felipe Manzo | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2012 |
| Emilee Margiotta | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2010 |
| Jorge Martinez | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1981, 1982 |
| Tino Martinez | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1986-3rd, 1987-2nd, 1988-1st |
| Matthew Mattingly | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2004, 2005, 2006 |
| Owen Matukas | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2022-1st |
| John Matuszak | Sport: Football | Years: 1972 |
| Ryan Maxwell | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2008-2nd |
| Katie McKiel | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2018-2nd, 2019-2nd |
| Alicia McLaughlin | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1981, 1982 |
| Scott McLearn | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1997, 1998, 2000 |
| Jennifer McLeod | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1997 |
| Johnny McMahan | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2005 |
| Leon McQuay | Sport: Football | Years: 1970 |
| Ronnie Merrill, Jr. | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2000-1st |
| Kyle Merritt | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2006, 2008 |
| Diana Mielke | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2004, 2005 |
| Ron Mikolajczyk | Sport: Football | Years: 1971 |
| Pascal Milien | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2008-1st, 2009-2nd |
| Sam Militello | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1988-3rd, 1989-1st, 1990-1st |
| Darren Miller | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2017-2nd |
| Owen Miller | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2022-2nd, 2023-2nd |
| Erik Mirza | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1996-2nd |
| Nick Mooney | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1981, 1982 |
| Lauren Moore | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2012-1st, 2014-3rd |
| Maureen Moore | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2019, 2020 |
| Elysia Moreland | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2001, 2002 |
| Tilde Morin | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| John Morring | Sport: Football | Years: 1970 |
| Julia Morrow | Sport: Softball | Years: 2014-3rd, 2015-3rd |
| Jake Mosher McGraw | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2018-2nd, 2019-2nd, 2020-2nd, 2021-3rd |
| Mika Muhonen | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1988-3rd |
| Meghann Mulbarger | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2004, 2005, 2007 |
| Steve Mumaw | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1984-2nd |
| Briana Murphy | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2014, 2015 |
| Patrick Murray | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2009 |
| Phil Murray | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2001, 2002, 2003 |
| Dori Nagy | Sport: Women's Basketball | Years: 2020-2nd |
| John Napier | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 1969-2nd |
| Gretchen Naruta | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2002-2nd, 2003-1st |
| Jay Nash | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1983 |
| Henrik Nebrelius | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1995-1st, 1996-2nd, 1997-1st |
| Braydon Nelson | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2022-1st |
| Cameron Newton | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2019 |
| Heather Nicolosi | Sport: Women's Cross Country | Years: 2010, 2011 |
| Sean Nizolek | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2022-1st |
| Philip Nordenberg | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2014 |
| Lacinda Norman | Sport: Softball | Years: 2003-2nd |
| Vesa Nurmiviita | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1998 |
| Amy O'Brien | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2011 |
| Molly O'Hara | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2018, 2019, 2020 |
| Chris O'Linger | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011 |
| Anja Oca | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| J.D. Osborne | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2017-1st |
| Ben Oshri | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2005 |
| Julia Oswald | Sport: Beach Volleyball | Years: 2021, 2023 |
| Preston Packrall | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2014-2nd |
| Roger Palm | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1996-1st |
| Catherine Parker | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2012 |
| Jeremy Parker | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2014, 2015, 2016 |
| Gabe Parnell | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Kahley Patrick | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2014-2nd |
| Anders Paulsson | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1997-1st |
| Courtney Peffley | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2012-3rd |
| Anthony Perez | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2008-1st |
| Sergio Perez | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2006-1st |
| John Perry | Sport: Football | Years: 1965 |
| Jamie Peterkin | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2003, 2004 |
| Kevin Peterson | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1987 |
| Damen Pheiffer | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2014 |
| Scott Phillips | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2020-3rd |
| Kylie Piche | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2012, 2013 |
| Karen Pitre | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1987, 1988 |
| Erin Plachy | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015 |
| Chris Plaisted | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1997 |
| Luke Posner | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2018-2nd |
| Sara Ragan | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2005 |
| Peter Ranstead | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2002, 2003 |
| Kara Rasmussen | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2006-2nd |
| Dawn Rawlins | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1996-2nd, 1998-2nd |
| Tom Reasoner | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1989-1st |
| Holly Reschke | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2012-3rd, 2014 - 2nd |
| Gene Reynolds | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2003-3rd |
| Andre Richardson | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Kiira Riihijarvi | Sport: Women's Golf | Years: 2017-2nd, 2018-2nd, 2019-1st, 2020-1st, 2021-1st |
| Claudia Rivera | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2021-2nd, 2023-2nd |
| Stephanie Rivera | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2005-2nd, 2006-1st |
| Meridith Roberts | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2003, 2004, 2005 |
| Samantha Robinson | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2005-3rd |
| Marc Rodriguez | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1993-3rd, 1994-3rd, 1995-1st |
| Alyssa Romano | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2023-2nd |
| Jake Rooney | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2014-3rd |
| Orlando Rosales | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2006-1st |
| Rachel Rosequist | Sport: Beach Volleyball | Years: 2021 |
| Bob Royak | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1982-2nd |
| Ania Ruiz | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2000-2nd, 2001-1st, 2002-1st, 2003-1st |
| Paul Russo | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1989-1st, 1990-1st |
| Carlee Sanchez-Hegarty | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Kevin Santa | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2017-2nd |
| Brett Saunders | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2019, 2020 |
| Jake Schmidt | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2016-3rd |
| Jeff Schroeder | Sport: Men's Golf | Years: 1988-3rd |
| Mike Schwartz | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2010-2nd |
| Danielle Selkridge | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2010-2nd, 2011-1st, 2012-1st |
| Roman Sereda | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2010 |
| Melissa Serio | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1997-1st |
| Katia Serkovic | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1992-2nd, 1993-2nd |
| George Shary | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 1963 |
| Meghan Sherman | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2009-1st, 2010-1st |
| Courtney Sherwood | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2019, 2020, 2022 |
| Kevin Shortt | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2001, 2002, 2003 |
| Austin Simpson | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Margeaux Sinibaldi | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2006-2nd, 2007-1st |
| Erin Sistek | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2023-3rd |
| Shawn Slade | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1993-3rd |
| Tim Slamkowski | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1997, 1998, 2000 |
| Al Smith | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1984-2nd |
| Mandy Smith | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004 |
| Yannick Smith | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2019, 2020 |
| Karen Solis | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1988-1st |
| Emily Stack | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2007-2nd |
| Matt Standley | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1994 |
| Allee Stelogeannis | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2016-1st |
| Bob Stevens | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 1968 |
| Trish Stevens | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1990 |
| McKenzie Street | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2019 |
| Donna Strong | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1982 |
| Chris Sullivan | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1987-1st, 1986-2nd |
| Chad Sundermeyer | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1996, 1997 |
| Bridget Sutter | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2020-2nd |
| Kris Sutton | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2000-1st, 2001-1st |
| Claire Swanson | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2019-1st, 2020-1st |
| Paul Swope | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1996 |
| Cole Tedhams | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2006 |
| Kim Tench | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2008 |
| Omar Thali | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2021-2nd |
| Vic Thixton | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 1967 |
| Gail Thompson | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 1985-87 |
| Ryan Thompson | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2008-3rd, 2009-1st |
| Justin Throneburg | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 1990-1st, 1991-2nd |
| Ozzie Timmons | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1990-2nd, 1991-1st |
| Tibor Tistan | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Jessie Tobin | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2020 |
| Yorvis Torrealba | Sport: Baseball | Years: 2019 |
| Shannon Treen | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004 |
| Malcolm Trier | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2005 |
| Jeff Tynes | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1981, 1983 |
| Jack Tyrrell | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2019-3rd |
| Blake Ulmer | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2021-3rd, 2022-1st, 2023-2nd |
| Joe Urso | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1991-2nd, 1992-2nd |
| Carly Vaccaro | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2019-3rd, 2020-3rd |
| Mike Valdes | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1997-1st, 1998-1st |
| Brian Valedon | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2019, 2020 |
| Emily Van De Wiele | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2023 |
| Magnus Van Koch | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 1982 |
| Hana Van Loock | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2018, 2019, 2020 |
| Melissa Vanderhall | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2008-1st, 2009-1st, 2010-1st |
| Michael Verdi | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2009 |
| Allison Vetter | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2009 |
| Julie Visser | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2003, 2004, 2005 |
| Roma Vrijhof | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2022, 2023 |
| Megan Waddell | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2018, 2019 |
| Jessica Wagner | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2014-1st, 2015-1st |
| Michelle Walcker | Sport: Women's Swimming | Years: 2011 |
| Alex Walling | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2023-2nd |
| Sheena Walton | Sport: Women's Basketball | Years: 2008-2nd |
| Joey Wardlow | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1988-2nd |
| Lister Warren | Sport: Men's Soccer | Years: 2009-3rd, 2010-3rd |
| Danielle Waters | Sport: Women's Lacrosse | Years: 2022-2nd, 2023-1st |
| Nick Waytovich | Sport: Football | Years: 1953 |
| Pat Weaver | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2002, 2003 |
| Lee Webber | Sport: Men's Swimming | Years: 2003, 2004, 2005 |
| Berkley Whaley | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2013-1st, 2014-1st, 2015-1st |
| Connor Whipple | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2014-2nd, 2015-3rd, 2016-2nd, 2017-1st |
| Bryan Williams | Sport: Men's Basketball | Years: 1990-2nd |
| Camryn Wineinger | Sport: Softball | Years: 2023-3rd |
| Malana Winskas | Sport: Women's Soccer | Years: 2006-1st |
| Susanne Wolmesjo | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 1985-2nd, 1987-2nd |
| Ericka Womack | Sport: Volleyball | Years: 2004-2nd, 2005-1st |
| Jack Wood | Sport: Men's Lacrosse | Years: 2021-2nd |
| Laura Woznicki | Sport: Women's Cross Country | Years: 2007 |
| Laura Woznicki | Sport: Women's Track | Years: 2008 |
| Brian Zalatel | Sport: Baseball | Years: 1992-2nd, 1993-1st |
| Baseball | 75 |
| Beach Volleyball | 6 |
| Football | 18 |
| Men's Basketball | 13 |
| Women's Basketball | 5 |
| Men's Cross Country | 1 |
| Women's Cross Country | 7 |
| Men's Golf | 14 |
| Women's Golf | 6 |
| Men's Lacrosse | 35 |
| Women's Lacrosse | 14 |
| Men's Soccer | 39 |
| Women's Soccer | 18 |
| Men's Swimming | 160 |
| Women's Swimming | 149 |
| Men's Track | 1 |
| Women's Track | 4 |
| Softball | 13 |
| Tennis | 1 |
| Volleyball | 68 |
| Wrestling | 4 |
| Total | 651 (through 2022-23) |